Wednesday, September 14, 2016

Dealing with The Past

Cambodia encountered the dark and destructive period known as the Khmer Rouge regime from 1975 to 1979, in which approximately two million people lost their lives mostly due to execution, starvation, overwork and torture.[1] The period has left Cambodia countless tragedy and unbelievable stories which shocked people throughout its history. Most of infrastructures, cultural and educational institutions were damaged, and most importantly entire generation of Cambodians was traumatized, and this trauma has been passed down to the next generation. The Khmer Rouge regime had a profound effect on Cambodia’s culture and people that will resonate for generations to come. Undoubtedly, the atrocity of the past that Cambodia faced does not happen by chance and the effect of it must be addressed. 

The Khmer Rouge regime which is considered the cruel mass killing of people, in overall assumption, occurred because of hatred and extreme belief as well as wrong ideology of the country’s top leaders. In fact, the Khmer Rouge's main aim was to get rid of capitalism[2] since they believed that anyone with money or education was superior. They wanted to rebuild a new Cambodia focused on agricultural success by building socialism in the fields.[3] They wanted everyone to become communists and to be equal. This demonstrates that in order to eliminate capitalism and bring equality to society, the Khmer Rouge’s leaders used their own mechanisms based on their own dominant belief of rebuilding their ideal society which is impossible to achieve. Particularly, absorbing with the strong intention which attempted to abolish private ownership and to strengthen the status of workers and peasants, the Khmer Rouge evacuated people who were considered as the threat to the regime. Besides, in order to purify the society, the Khmer Rouge cleaned both internal and external enemies. They took all roots of threat to make sure that no one could rebel against the regime. Notably, those classified as internal enemies were the new people whose status was categorized as capitalist or who were not ethnically Khmer, including officials of the Khmer Republic government, minority groups, Cham Muslims, Vietnamese, ethnic Chinese, intellectuals, and alleged traitors. External enemies referred to the US and its allies such as Thailand and some socialist countries, especially Vietnam and the Soviet Union, which the Khmer Rouge felt attempted to invade Cambodia and make it their colony.[4] Because the Khmer Rouge held a strong communist ideology and did not follow the good principles of Buddhism which requires people to respect other people’s lives, they systematically killed all their enemies and eliminated religious establishments. For example, the Khmer Rouge’s revolutionary struggled to create the first real communist society, and abolished religion as well as prohibited religious worship. Buddhism, which had been served as the basic source of Khmer identity[5], was seen as a threat to the revolutionary struggle for a homogenized population, because it was seen as civilizing and contributing to the social evolution of the peoples. Consequently, many Cambodians had been categorized as the Khmer Rouge’s enemies, creating a situation in which Khmer were killing Khmer people.[6]  

After the Khmer Rouge regime collapsed, we learn that individual Cambodians faced the loss of family members and the psychological effects of living through extreme trauma, while often living nearby former Khmer Rouge cadres.[7] Throughout Cambodia, people are still suffering from the tragedy and many have yet to overcome the emotional trauma of having lived under the Khmer Rouge regime. Every family in Cambodia was affected by the genocide – as victims, perpetrators or both in many cases. Anyone who disobeyed orders paid with their own life. Many who became murderers thus see themselves as victims, forced to commit crimes against their will. The consequences are feelings of guilt and shame – and a widespread inability to talk about personal experiences. Although much has been done to integrate former fighters into the population, there is still a degree of distance between former Khmers Rouge and their victims, as well as the rest of society. The Khmer Rouge identity remains embedded deep within the psyche, combined with the fear of being discriminated against or implicated in some way that might bring them before the tribunal. Shame, denial, and fear are barriers that encourage former Khmers Rouge to avoid discussions of history, particularly when such conversations turn to their personal experiences. For the same reasons, many former Khmer Rouge discourage their children from learning the relevant history. This has made genocide education all the more challenging in former regime strongholds in the areas where many former Khmers Rouge still reside.[8] 

In order to deal with the past, work must be done to bring down these barriers and create a more meaningful interpersonal and national reconciliation. Before we can have a culture of empathy and understanding, we must first have an environment that permits and encourages dialogue. This should not take place only between victims, but also with former Khmers Rouge. This open discourse could take place either in less formal spaces, such as homes or villages, or in more formal ones, such as schools or public forums. And for the former Khmers Rouge to open up without fear of repercussions, more efforts need to be made to ensure public understanding of the scope of the tribunal, which prosecutes only the most senior and most responsible persons.[9] Importantly, the victims should be provided with either retributive justice or restorative justice. Regarding retributive justice, which focuses on the legal and procedural conception of justice, the victims should get a verdict of the perpetrators’ guilt. For instance, the ECCC plays a crucial role in finding the truth and justice for victim survivors and healing their past. Furthermore, in terms of restorative justice which emphasizes on the emotional components of justice, the use of Buddhist teachings as a base for reconciliation is worth.[10] These two categories represent the two dimensions of justice for the survivors of the Khmer Rouge regime, demonstrating the necessity for both legal ramifications and emotional reconciliation among the survivors.[11]  By creating memorials, doing art work such as painting or drawing the past experience, and performing other memorialization initiatives, it gives priceless legacy in which Cambodian society gives validation to those who survived from the Khmer Rouge period, honors those who died during the Khmer Rouge, and helps establish a historical record for and awareness in the international community by means of tourists’ exposure to such memorials.[12] 

However, what we, Cambodians, can do to build a peaceful and harmonized society is to bring the concept of peace to the mind of people and engage them in activities that can heal their past and live without fear, anger or revenge. We educate young people and engage them in social reconciliation. We create space for young people to gain knowledge by interviewing during inter-generational dialogue with their family and other survivors. Through history education, young people can get a deeper understanding of the past and are willing to study and work harder in order to prevent atrocities in the future.  In addition, initiating dialogue between former Khmer Rouge and victims enables victims and their direct perpetrators to face each other, encourages former Khmer Rouge cadres to face their own history of wrongdoing, helps strengthen community relationships in order for villagers to move forward together towards social cohesion and to ensure that future generations will not inherit a fragmented community life. Moreover, we can work to reduce and eliminate the concept of stereotype, prejudice, or discrimination against the children of the former Khmer Rouge and beyond that to get them more closer and build good relationship with each other.  What’s more, we encourage victims to tell the truth of their experience during the Khmer Rouge regime because it helps release their anger and pain. Initiative such social repair programs would be beneficial to Cambodian ways of life, especially local rituals of managing, reducing and resolving conflicts.[13] 

To sum up, the trauma of the genocide which occurred because of extreme belief in communism of the Khmer Rouge’s top leaders is still very fresh and raw for those who have survived, and that collective trauma was even passed down to later generations. It creates the condition that the victim survivors and the perpetrators are living together with full of fear, anger, hatred, and pain. However, the gap between them must be closed by creating dialogue, the truth must be found to acknowledge the pain of victims, and justice must be provided in both forms, retributive justice and restorative justice. Finally, the concept of peace must be promoted through education, and reconciliation must be gained in society via the participation of all people. At the same time, Cambodian people should not try to forget the past and in contrast we should learn to prevent the atrocity and to live in peace and harmony.



[1] Khamboly, Dy.(2007). A History of Democratic Kampuchea (1975-1979). Documentation Center of Cambodia. Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
[2] Amendola, Amber. (2005). The Khmer Rouge and Pol Pot's Regime: The Cambodian Genocide. http://www.mtholyoke.edu/~amamendo/KhmerRouge.html
[3] David P. Chandler (1983). A History of Cambodia. Fourth Edition
[4] Khamboly, Dy.(2007). A History of Democratic Kampuchea (1975-1979). Documentation Center of Cambodia. Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
[5] Charles, Keyes.(1990). Buddhism and Revolution in Cambodia. Cultural Survival. http://www.culturalsurvival.org/publications/cultural-survival-quarterly/cambodia/buddhism-and-revolution-cambodia
[6] Bach, Nastasia and Deane, Meridith. (2009). Breaking the Silence: Achieving Justice and Reconciliation in Post-Genocide Cambodia. Documentation Center of Cambodia.
[7] Veneciano, Jorge D and Aexander Hinton.(2007). Night of the Khmer Rouge: Genocide and Justice in Cambodia.
[8] Kry, Suyheang and Chy, Terith. (2015). Forty Years after Khmer Rouge Victory, Has Cambodia Dealt with Its Past? IN ASIA. http://asiafoundation.org/in-asia/2015/04/22/forty-years-after-khmer-rouge-victory-has-cambodia-dealt-with-its-past/
[9] ECCC. (2008). Introduction to the ECCC. http://www.eccc.gov.kh/en/about-eccc/introduction
[10] The Sunday Times. (210). A Buddhist path to reconciliation. http://www.sundaytimes.lk/101114/Plus/plus_15.html
[11] Linton, Suzannah. (2004). Reconciliation in Cambodia. Documentation Center of Cambodia.
[12] Bach, Nastasia and Deane, Meridith. (2009). Breaking the Silence: Achieving Justice and Reconciliation in Post-Genocide Cambodia. Documentation Center of Cambodia.
[13] Linton, Suzannah. (2004). Reconciliation in Cambodia. Documentation Center of Cambodia.

No comments:

Post a Comment